6/22/2007

The topic of Scapular Loading (aka, Scapula Loading, Inverted W, or "M") has come up in a number of discussions on the message boards that I frequent, and I thought I ought to discuss my view of Scapular Loading.

Scapular Loading

Nolan Ryan

If you look at photos of most major league pitchers, like Nolan Ryan, you will see that at some point in their motion, usually just before their Pitching Arm Side (aka PAS) forearm is about to pass through the vertical, high-cocked position and their shoulders start to rotate, they take their elbows behind their back and pinch their shoulder blades (or Scapulae) together. Paul Nyman's theory is that this action helps to load the muscles on both sides of the shoulder and enables a pitcher to throw harder.
     While I will not disagree that many pitchers seem to do this, I do question whether it has the effect that Paul Nyman thinks it does (due to the relatively small size of the muscles involved). As a result, Scapular Loading is not something that I focus on when teaching or evaluating pitchers. However, I believe that there appears to be a safe way to load one's scaps and an unsafe way to load one's scaps.

THE SAFE WAY TO LOAD ONE'S SCAPS
In my opinion, the safe way to load one's scaps is to always keep the elbows below the level of the shoulders as Nolan Ryan is doing in the photo above. I believe that this, which I call the "W", reduces the level of the strain that are put on the ligaments that hold the shoulder together and reduces the amount, and force with which, the PAS upper arm externally rotates.

Randy Johnson
If you look at photos of Randy Johnson, who has had a long, successful career and has been free of shoulder and elbow problems, you will see that he makes the "W" and always keeps his elbows below the level of his shoulders after he breaks his hands.

Randy Johnson

Randy Johnson

The two photos above of Randy Johnson show exactly what I mean. Notice that while his elbows are behind his back, they are also well below the level of his shoulders.

Randy Johnson

You can see the same thing in the the photo above of Randy Johnson, which is from the same moment but from a different angle. Again, notice that his elbows are behind his back but well below the level of his shoulders during the process of Scapular Loading.

Randy Johnson

Above is a third view of Randy Johnson from the same moment in time that shows the exact same thing. Randy Johnson's elbows are behind his back but below the level of his shoulders.

Randy Johnson

Randy Johnson

Randy Johnson

Randy Johnson

To prove that this is something that Randy Johnson still does, above are four photos of him from early on in the 2007 season. Notice how his PAS elbow always stays below the level of his shoulders.

Randy Johnson

You can see the same thing in the above video clip of Randy Johnson. Notice how his PAS elbow always stays below the level of his shoulders until after his PAS forearm has passed through the vertical high-cocked position. His PAS elbow is at the level of his shoulders at the Release Point, but that is normal.

Randy Johnson

For those of you who are not clear what I am talking about, here is a frame from the clip above.
     In this frame, the solid white line represents the degree to which Randy Johnson's torso is tilted forward toward 1B. The solid yellow line is this frame represents the level of his shoulders as measured by the Acromial processes. As you can see, as Randy Johnson is at his point of maximum Scapular Loading and his PAS upper arm starts to externally rotate, his PAS elbow is well below the level of his shoulders. Probably 6 to 9 inches by my count.

Greg Maddux
You can see exactly the same "W" pattern in photos of Greg Maddux, another pitcher who has had a long, successful career and who has been free of elbow and shoulder problems.

Greg Maddux

In the photo above of Greg Maddux, notice the same pattern as in the arm action of Randy Johnson. While his elbows are indeed behind his back, they are also well below the level of his shoulders.

Greg Maddux

Above is another photo of Greg Maddux taken at almost exactly the same moment. Again, notice that while his elbows are indeed behind his back, they are also well below the level of his shoulders during the process of Scapular Loading.

Greg Maddux

Above is another photo of Greg Maddux taken from a slightly different angle that shows the same thing. Notice that his elbows are behind his back, but well below the level of his shoulders.

Greg Maddux

Above is a third view of Greg Maddux, this time taken from the side. Again, notice how low Greg Maddux's PAS elbow is relative to the level of his shoulders.

Greg Maddux

Above is a recent view of Greg Maddux taken from early May 2007. You can see that he does today what he did back in his days in Atlanta; he keeps his PAS elbow below the level of his shoulders after breaking his hands.

Greg Maddux

Greg Maddux

Finally, above are two views of Greg Maddux from June 2007 showing how he keeps his elbows below the level of his shoulders during the act of Scapula Loading.

Roger Clemens
If you look at photos of Roger Clemens, you will see the same "W" form in his arms.

Roger Clemens

Notice in the photo above, that while Roger Clemens' elbows are behind his back, they are also below the level of his shoulders during the process of Scapular Loading.

Roger Clemens

You can see the same thing in this more recent photo of Roger Clemens. His elbows are just behind his back but also just below the level of his shoulders.

Roger Clemens

In this side view of Roger Clemens you can also see that while he is loading his scaps, his elbow never gets above the level of his shoulders.

Tom Seaver
You can see the same basic "W" pattern in the mechanics of Tom Seaver.

Tom Seaver

Notice in the photo above of Tom Seaver that his PAS forearm is vertical but his PAS elbow is below the level of his shoulders during the process of Scapular Loading.

Sandy Koufax
Although it's a bit harder to see, you can also see the same "W" pattern in the mechanics of Sandy Koufax.

Sandy Koufax

Notice in the photo above of Sandy Koufax that his PAS forearm is vertical and his PAS elbow, which is barely visible behind his back, is below the level of his shoulders during the process of Scapular Loading.

THE DANGEROUS WAY TO LOAD ONE'S SCAPS
If you compare and contrast how Nolan Ryan, Randy Johnson, Greg Maddux, and Roger Clemens load their scaps with how pitchers with shoulder problems load their scaps, you will see a difference that I believe is significant. In general, this difference comes down to the position of the PAS elbow; it tends to be much higher around the high-cocked position in pitchers with shoulder problems and their arms form an "M" rather than a "W". I use the term Hyperabduction to describe the general problem of excessive elevation of the PAS elbow.

Mark Prior
The poster child for the dangerous way to load one's scaps has to be Mark Prior, a pitcher who showed tremendous promise but who has been plagued with elbow and now shoulder problems.

Mark Prior

The thing to notice in the photo above is how high Mark Prior's PAS elbow is as he starts the process of Scapular Loading. His PAS elbow is several inches above the level of his shoulders and his arms make a clear "M". This stands in sharp contrast to the height of the PAS elbows of Nolan Ryan, Randy Johnson, Greg Maddux, and Roger Clemens.

Mark Prior

The photo above of Mark Prior shows the same thing. Notice that he is starting to load his scaps, but with his PAS elbow well above, rather than below, the level of his shoulders.
     If you want to understand the root cause of Mark Prior's problems, then the two pictures above are an excellent starting point.

Billy Wagner
Billy Wagner is another pitcher who has had a series of shoulder problems and who also loads his scaps while his PAS elbow is well above the level of his shoulders.

Billy Wagner

In the photo above, you can see Billy Wagner just starting to load his scaps. You can also see that his PAS elbow is well above the level of his shoulders.

Billy Wagner

You can see the same thing in the photo above of Billy Wagner. Notice how he is starting to load his scaps while his PAS elbow is still quite high relative to the level of his shoulders.

PREDICTIONS
Now that I've laid out the basics of my theory, let me make some predictions about the fates of different pitchers based on how they load their scaps. We can then see how my theory holds up over time.

PITCHERS WHOSE ARM ACTION I LIKE
Below are photos and comments about pitchers who load their scaps in a way that I think is safe, and who make more of a "W" than an "M". As a result, I believe that these pitchers should be less prone than most to shoulder problems.

Dan Haren
Dan Haren is a pitcher whose arm action I like a lot.

Dan Haren

As you can see in the photo above, as he loads his scaps, Dan Haren keeps his PAS elbow below the level of his shoulders, which is good. The more I see of Dan Haren, the more I rue the day the Cardinals traded him and wish they had traded Anthony Reyes instead. However, I have to hand it to the A's for recognizing his talent.

Roy Oswalt
Despite the fact that he plays for the Astros, I am a big fan of Roy Oswalt and his arm action in part because he makes the "W".

Roy Oswalt

As the photo above of Roy Oswalt shows, as he loads his scaps he keeps his elbows below the level of his shoulders.

Roy Oswalt

You can see the same thing in the photo above of Roy Oswalt. As he loads his scaps, his elbows are below the level of his shoulders.

Dontrelle Willis
I have some concerns about Dontrelle Willis' arm action, because his PAS elbow gets a little high early on in his delivery.

Dontrelle Willis

However, as the photo above shows, as his PAS forearm passes through the vertical high-cocked position and he loads his scaps, his elbows are below the level of his shoulders and his arms form more of "W" shape than an "M".

PITCHERS I AM WORRIED ABOUT
Below are photos of and comments about pitchers who load their scaps in a way that I think increases the likelihood that they will have shoulder problems, especially if they are starting pitchers.

Aaron Heilman
Aaron Heilman is another pitcher with what I think is a problematic arm action.

Aaron Heilman

As you can see in the photo above, Aaron Heilman's arm action is very similar to Billy Wagner's. Notice how high his PAS elbow gets relative to the level of his shoulders.

Anthony Reyes
If you are familiar with my work, you know that I have a low opinion of Anthony Reyes of the Cardinals. This is because Anthony Reyes' arm action is very similar to Mark Prior's and he makes a very pronounced "M". As a result, I expect that Anthony Reyes will have many of the same problems as Mark Prior.

Anthony Reyes

The photo above shows that Anthony Reyes comes to the same "M" or  Inverted W position as Mark Prior, with his PAS elbows both above and behind the level of his shoulders.

Anthony Reyes

You can see the same thing going on in the photo above of Anthony Reyes. Notice how high his PAS elbow is relative to the level of his shoulders.

Anthony Reyes

You can see the same thing in the photo above of Anthony Reyes. Again, notice the height of his PAS elbow (and his PAS forearm hanging down vertically beneath it).